• home
  • about
  • books
  • links

Archive for February, 2010

« Older Entries
Newer Entries »

Much Ado About Book Reviewing

Monday, February 22nd, 2010

Previous Post – Of Gates & Fruits – SOTM Series (13)

The Naked Anabaptist: The Bare Essentials of a Radical Faith

With all the buzz about Brian McLaren’s new book, a sub-conversation has surfaced on the topic of bloggers reviewing for publishers.  Core to this discussion is the concern that publishers are taking quite a bit of advantage of bloggers to generate a lot of free buzz, usually at the minimal expense of sending out a few key review copies of the book in question.  Bloggers are doing a very valuable service for publishers, which in the past would have cost them a great deal of money.  Conversely is the problem of those who do get paid to review and promote books, but who do not disclose this fact.  Bill Kinnon weighs in, as does Jordon Cooper.

My own experience with this has been mixed.  I have participated in a number of programs or agreements with publisher and organizations where I would review books for free.  Some were less than appealing, even uncomfortable in the pressure to review something I was not interested in and/or seriously displeased with.  However, I have also had some great experiences.  For example, anyone who reads my blog will know that I review a fair amount of InterVarsity Press titles.  IVPress has been a wonderful publisher to partner with, allowing me to choose titles I am interested in and encouraging honest reviews (both positive and negative).  IVPress has related to me more as a ministry than a business (though of course sales are not important to them).  The free titles I have received have been adequate compensation for me.  Other groups could learn something from this clearly missionally minded group of people.

In respect to being paid, this is a new topic for me, as I have never been paid to do any online reviewing or promo.  However, that changed recently in a very pleasant way.  When I learned the Stuart Murray’s new book “The Naked Anabaptist: The Bare Essentials of a Radical Faith” was due to release soon, I contact Stuart to request a review copy.  He kindly connected me with the folks at Herald Press.  Turned out the person I needed to talk to was not only working out of Winnipeg, but was a friend of mine.  Knowing me as a blogger, we decided to get together for coffee.  During our chat, I mentioned different way Herald Press could leverage social media to help get the word out.  As a result, he asked if I would be willing to try to help them do this, offering to pay for the work.

Here are the critical factors that should be noted in this decision:

  • Herald Press is a small publishing house that, while still a business, is clearly geared towards getting their material into the right hands for meaningful impact on the church.
  • Herald Press offered to pay me, not only because they felt my time was worth it, but because they knew it would help support a missionary pastor.
  • Herald Press was explicit that they did not want me to review anything that I didn’t not fully believe in, requiring honest review of the material regardless of whether it was positive or not.
  • I approached them first, offering to help spread the word for free.  They were under no obligation to offer me compensation.
  • Knowing Stuart Murray and his work, and having read excerpts from The Naked Anabaptist, I knew this was a project I could excitedly help promote.
  • I hesitated accepting compensation out of the risk that, on disclosing it, readers would questions the sincerity of the review (something I am still concerned about)

This topic is a fascinating one for me.  The reality is that the internet and the struggling publishing world are coming together in a new relationship, one in which these kinds of questions will become increasingly important to grapple.  I would affirm that bloggers who want to make the most of this new relationship should identify their own values and boundaries, establishing clear agreements with any publisher or author.  Be discerning, honest and realistic.  If this loses you a free book or two, it is worth it in the long run.

What do you think?  Does my disclosure change the way you will view my reviews?  Any advice for bloggers?

Tags: book review, Books, Missional, publishing
Posted in Books, Missional | 18 Comments »

Of Gates & Fruits – SOTM Series (14)

Sunday, February 21st, 2010

Previous Post – What Kind Of Christian Are You?

Part 1 – Setting the Stage

Part 2 – Beatitudes (1)

Part 3 – Beatitudes (2)

Part 4 – Salt & Light/Law

Part 5 – Murder/Adultery/Divorce

Part 6 – Oaths, Eyes & Enemies

Part 7 – Hiding In Plain Sight

Part 8 – The Lord’s Prayer (1)

Part 9 – The Lord’s Prayer (2)

Part 10 – Fasting

Part 11 – Don’t Worry, Be Righteous

Part 12 – Judging Others

Part 13 – Ask, Seek, Knock

“Enter through the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to destruction, and many enter through it. But small is the gate and narrow the road that leads to life, and only a few find it.” Matthew 7:13,14

Once again, Jesus is pointing out to His listeners that follow Him is a singular choice- you either follow or you do not.  There is no third (or any other) option.  There is one Master and one path of obedience.  But what is this path?  Is the narrow path about doctrine?  Is it about developing an idealistic life ethic?  Of course these aspects are present, but this is not what Jesus is primarily calling us to.  He calls us to an uncompromising fidelity of love.  It is the single-minded faithfulness of a lover.

It many ways, a straight and narrow path is the easiest kind of path to follow.  The way is clear and direct.  Conversely, a wide and meandering path can leave much room for error.  It reminds me of the men who were canoeing down the southern end of the Mississippi River during flood season.  They were sure they were following the flow of the river until the floated past a mailbox and a stop sign.  The path had spilled so wide that it had not clear direction at all.

The straight and narrow is not difficult because it offers an impossible ethic to live out (for Jesus constantly leaves room for grace in the face of mistakes), but rather it is difficult because of what it costs.  Have you ever stood on the high board of the high dive at an Olympic sized pool?  Jumping off that height is simple- you just take the step.  Yet for most of us, we are crippled by uncertainty, fear and anxiety.  It is reminiscent of G.K. Chesterton’s words: “Christianity has not been tried and found wanting.  It has been found difficult and left untried”.  This is so because the narrow gate is the gate of the Cross of Christ, where everything is left behind and we embrace death in order to find resurrection life.

“Watch out for false prophets. They come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ferocious wolves. By their fruit you will recognize them. Do people pick grapes from thorn bushes, or figs from thistles? Likewise every good tree bears good fruit, but a bad tree bears bad fruit. A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, and a bad tree cannot bear good fruit. Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire. Thus, by their fruit you will recognize them.” Matthew 7:15-20

Jesus makes it clear that, as we seek to follow Him in obedience to how He calls us to live, there will be those who will seek to mislead us.  Unlike the cartoonish villains of pop culture, these false teachers will appear to one of us.  While their appearance will be that of a fellow believer of Christ, their hearts will have the intentions of a wolf.  Again, in this Jesus is reminding us that it is the heart that is the source of our character.

However, He also reaffirms that out of the heart our real natures will be made evident in our lives.  Just like a tree can be known by the nature of fruit it produces, so too does the fruit of our lives give evidence of what kind of person we are.  Fruit is the outward product of the inward nature.  But what are these fruit?  What are we to look for?  In the Sermon on the Mount we learn what such fruit is, especially in the Beatitudes.  In Matthew 12:32-34, we learn that our words are the fruit borne of our hearts.  In John 15, Jesus makes it clear that good fruit that is born from Christ within us will be characterized by sacrificial and selfless love.  Later, in Galatians, Paul describes the fruit of the Spirit- love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control.

All of these things together represent the fruit that we should look for in peoples lives.  However, like fruit that takes time to grow and come into maturity, we must not too quickly rush to judge people (remember this?), allowing instead for their fruit mature and become evident.  Jesus is not giving us license to become heresy-hunter or truth-police.  We must be careful and vigilant, but also patient and humble.  Only God can truly judge.

“Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only he who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. Many will say to me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and in your name drive out demons and perform many miracles?’ Then I will tell them plainly, ‘I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!’” Matthew 7:21-23

In these words, Jesus is again call us into the tension between right belief and right action.  He puts neither orthodoxy nor orthopraxy ahead of the other, but makes it clear that true obedience to Him will be reflect in both.  However, even when we believe right doctrine and live righteous lives, this is not enough.  Yes, we must confess with our mouths and believe in our hearts, but this is not suggesting allegiance to a moral, ethical or religious system, but rather to devotion to the very real God- Father, Son and Spirit.  God must know us, be in real, active and dynamic relationship with us.  He is a very present God who will not be satisfied by the most fervent devotion to His ideals.  He wants us to love and worship Him.

Of course, this will produce belief and righteous living.  However, Jesus makes it explicitly clear in the equivalent verses in Luke: “Why do you call me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ and do not do what I say?” (Luke 6:46).  We must do what He says.  True belief- like truth- is fully manifested when it is incarnated.  Jesus is that incarnation and, as His Body, we are to be incarnational expressions of our beliefs.  We are not saved by our works, but faith without works is no faith at all.

This devotion must touch every part of our lives, both public and private.  No time or place is exempt from this radical call to absolute obedience.  It is the one path, the one gate, the one and only way.  It is Jesus Christ.

Tags: Jesus, Missional, sermon on the mount
Posted in Community, Missional, church | 4 Comments »

« Older Entries
Newer Entries »
  • RT @efcaSW: ?@missional: Not surprised, but still sad yesterday prompted dozens of people 2 "unfriend" me. Conversation is costly. http: ... # 2012/01/26
    Follow Me

  • You are currently browsing the Jamie Arpin-Ricci – Blog blog archives for February, 2010 .

    • Adoption (13)
    • Advent (5)
    • Anabaptism (23)
    • Bible (34)
    • Books (70)
    • church (55)
    • Church Planting (34)
    • Community (149)
    • Discipleship (30)
    • Easter (1)
    • emerging church (4)
    • Evangelism (18)
    • Film (9)
    • Gospel (49)
    • Jesus (34)
    • Justice (73)
    • Leadership (23)
    • Missional (249)
    • Money (6)
    • Pastors (9)
    • Peace (17)
    • Personal (13)
    • prayer (6)
    • Sexuality (3)
    • St. Francis (34)
    • Third Place (6)
    • Uncategorized (245)
    • 2012
    • 2011
    • 2010
    • 2009
    • 2008
    • 2007

Jamie Arpin-Ricci – Blog is proudly powered by WordPress
Site Design by SoloDesign.ca
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).